Posted on May 16, 2008 by Wayan Vota in People: Negroponte

In the midst of the latest Windows on the XO controversy, Nicholas Negroponte seems to have announced a third new mission statement for One Laptop Per Child. From his email to the OLPC Sugar list serve he says that the OLPC mission hasn't changed in three years, and then points to this statement:

olpc mission
To eliminate poverty and create world peace by providing education to the poorest and most remote children on the planet by making them more active in their own learning, through collaborative and creative activities, connected to the Internet, with their own laptop, as a human right and cost free to them.
Now unless I just came down with Negropontism, the current OLPC mission statement on Laptop.org doesn't look anything like that. Please correct me if I am wrong, but I don't see any mention of free laptops and Internet access as basic human right when I read:
OLPC is not, at heart, a technology program, nor is the XO a product in any conventional sense of the word. OLPC is a non-profit organization providing a means to an end—an end that sees children in even the most remote regions of the globe being given the opportunity to tap into their own potential, to be exposed to a whole world of ideas, and to contribute to a more productive and saner world community.
Let's also not forget that the current OLPC mission, whichever one it is, was not the first mission espoused by One Laptop Per Child. The orginal OLPC mission was much more revolutionary, and to use a word from Walter Bender, prescriptive:
OLPC is not at heart a technology program and the XO is not a product in any conventional sense of the word. We are non-profit: constructionism is our goal; XO is our means of getting there. It is a very cool, even revolutionary machine, and we are very proud of it. But we would also be delighted if someone built something better, and at a lower price.
I wonder, does Windows XO count as better?

Tags: | | | | | |

Posted on May 16, 2008 by Guest Writer in People: Negroponte

Nicholas Negroponte's email attachment to the OLPC Sugar listserv

One Laptop per Child is announcing an agreement with Microsoft to make a dual boot, Linux/Windows, version of the XO laptop. In addition, our intention is to engage one or more third parties to port Sugar to run on Windows in order to reach a wider installed base of laptops.


Nicholas Negroponte of OLPC

In the meanwhile, OLPC remains fully committed to our goal: a completely free and open learning platform for the world's children. The mission statement of OLPC has not changed in three years (attached). Sugar is the first user interface specifically designed for children and teachers to learn and collaborate, and remains central to our strategy.

Broadening Sugar's reach to as many children as possible remains key to OLPC's mission. To enable the Sugar environment to reach as many children as possible, particularly in the poorest areas of the world, OLPC must be able to bid on educational technology contracts, some of which require that Microsoft Windows be able to run on our hardware.

The increased volumes will lower the XO-1's price, already lowest in the industry with capabilities no other laptop shares. OLPC is substantially increasing its engineering resources and all software development continues entirely on GNU/Linux We will continue to work to make Sugar on Linux the best possible platform for education and to invest in our expanding Linux deployments in Peru, Uruguay, Mexico and elsewhere.

No OLPC resources are going to porting Sugar to Microsoft Windows, although as a free software project, we encourage others to do so. The Sugar user interface is already available for Fedora, Debian and Ubuntu Linux distributions, greatly broadening Sugar's reach to the millions of existing Linux systems. We continue to solicit help from the free software community in these efforts.

Additionally, the Fedora, Debian and Ubuntu software environments run on the XO-1, adding support for tens of thousands of free software applications. Open Firmware V2, the free and open source BIOS, is now capable of running Linux, Microsoft Windows XP and other operating systems, and was developed by Firmworks with support from OLPC.

This will enable dual boot of OLPC XO laptops with Microsoft Windows XP in addition to the existing Fedora-based system and will become the standard BIOS/bootloader for all XO systems when completed. With this "free BIOS" the XO-1 continues to be the most open laptop hardware currently available.

For more information, see http://wiki.laptop.org/go/AnnounceFAQ

Nicholas Negroponte's email attachment to the OLPC Sugar listserv

Tags: | | | | | | | |

Posted on May 02, 2008 by Wayan Vota in People: Leadership, People: Negroponte

Nicholas Negroponte has finally found his new CEO for One laptop Per Child. After a year of fruitless searching, he's tapped Charles Kane, OLPC's CFO and a former software company executive, to lead the organization on a daily basis.

mako xo laptop
Charles Kane of OLPC

And what does Charles say about OLPC's mission, now that he's running the show? According to Technology Review, Charles is very clear: it’s a laptop project.

"The OLPC mission is a great endeavor, but the mission is to get the technology in the hands of as many children as possible," he said. "Whether that technology is from one operating system or another, one piece of hardware or another, or supplied or supported by one consulting company or another doesn't matter."

"It's about getting it into kids' hands," he continued. "Anything that is contrary to that objective, and limits that objective, is against what the program stands for."

Now what might Charles be referring to when he talks about things limiting the program? Charles doesn't say explicitly, but we can always look to Nicholas Negroponte, still Chairman of OLPC, for an answer. And he's very clear on what he finds as a distraction to One Laptop Per Child's success:
"I think that means and ends, as often happens, got confused," he says. "The mission is learning and children. The means of achieving that were, amongst others, open source and constructionism.

In the process of doing that, open source in particular became an end in itself, and we made decisions along the way to remain very pure in open source that were not in the long-term interest of the project."

So kids, there you have it. The time, effort, energy, and passion of an entire global network of FOSS experts and supporters who have coded and promoted thousands of hours for OLPC, are actually a hindrance to success.

Now why is that? How could that be? Oh, let us have our Dear Leader tell us what he believes is the true roadblocks to XO laptop adoption:

negroponte
An empty OLPC soul
"When I went to Egypt for the first time, I met separately with the minister of communications, minister of education, minister of science and technology, and the prime minister, and each one of them, within the first three sentences, said, 'Can you run Windows?'" Negroponte says.

One future possibility is a "dual-boot" version of the OLPC machine, in which either Windows or Linux can be launched at start-up. If such a scheme were to materialize, Negroponte says, "I expect we will do a massive rollout in Egypt."

Yes, Nicholas, with Windows XO, you will have a massive roll out of low-cost laptops. It will be a great win for you, for Quanta, and maybe even for the OLPC organization.

Its only too bad you'll be celebrating alone.

The children, constructionist educators, and the entire FOSS community that brought you to this point, will not be cheering. In fact, I date this week as the beginning of the end for Open Source support of the OLPC organization. It sure marks the end for me.

Walter, you want a blog?

Tags: | | | | | | |

.

Posted on April 27, 2008 by Guest Writer in People: Negroponte

As I agree with Bibek Paudel, I've re-posted his email from Sugar Listserv
olpc negroponte
Nicholas Negroponte of OLPC
Hi all. While I personally think it is bad for OLPC to switch to Windows XP, here a few observations that I have made:

1. Any development/education project meant for third world countries is best when it is natively grown. A top down approach where some guy in Boston teaches us how to change things in our neighbourhood is never likely to understand and respect our situation and problems. He has other priorities.

A bottom-up approach should be devised where grassroot organizations from different parts of the world collaborate to form a mother organization that works in their benefit. Compare this to Nepal's political situation where every other politician/media claims to represent the people and be working for them. Things won't that way in technology too.

2. Nicholas Negroponte is a man hungry of some position in history of business and humanity, both. He thinks increasing the sales of laptops is more important than the growing impact it is creating. Selling a quarter of a million of laptops is a success by any means for any profit-organization. I don't understand how it is not sufficient in case of a first-of-its-kind project by a non-profit organization.

Tags: | | | | | | |

Posted on April 24, 2008 by Guest Writer in People: Negroponte


Walter Bender and Nicholas Negroponte
Nicholas, with all due respect, I think you're pretty seriously mischaracterizing the nature of One Laptop Per Child's problems. Laying the blame for OLPC's shortcomings at the feet of "open source fundamentalists" is misinformed at best and deliberately disingenuous at worst.

Now, to be clear: when you say that "Sugar needs to run on many platforms," I completely agree with you. I couldn't possibly agree more. But moving from that point, which is clearly correct, to an ad hominem attack on the open source community as a whole, is a frustrating and dangerous non-sequitor, and a slap in the face to the people who have been your most strident supporters for many years now.

When a man like Walter Bender walks away from your shared dream because he feels like you are choosing the wrong path, then maybe you should consider being a bit more introspective, instead of lashing out at the big bad free software fundies.

Did Walter, your friend for 30 years, the guy with whom you built the MIT Media Lab, turn into a fundamentalist whack job over night? Really?

Tags: | | | | | |

Posted on April 24, 2008 by Guest Writer in People: Negroponte

One Laptop Per Child needs high quality software on its machines, but the amount of abuse ladled out over OLPC's developer community is incredible. First they are called "terrorists", and then it was "fundamentalists".
olpc windows xo
The future XO OS?
Nicholas Negroponte now seems to think that all of Sugar's problems can be solved by outsourcing a Sugar-on-Windows port to developers in Uruguay, who will be funded by Microsoft.

In a clever rhetorical trick, this allows OLPC to continue to insist that it "gets no money from Microsoft" and that it "pays no money to Windows developers" even though it employs a number of people who (presently and in the future) work full- or part-time on supporting the Windows-on-XO effort.

Any competent management team would realize that this fanciful porting effort spells nothing but years of delay, while time is spent refactoring Sugar for the port (and not adding needed features!); Negroponte apparently exists in a dream world where Microsoft is a benevolent software company which both cares about the world's children and plays nicely with its smaller "partners".

Tags: | | | | | |

Posted on April 23, 2008 by Guest Writer in People: Negroponte


Nicholas Negroponte of OLPC
Nicholas Negroponte's email attachment to the Community News listserv

Yes, OLPC’s commitment to Sugar has changed. It is now larger, not smaller. Contrary to inferences drawn by Walter’s departure, the press and venerable sources such as OLPC News, we are scaling Sugar up, not down. Let me explain.

Sugar is a very good idea, less than perfectly executed. I attribute our weakness to unrealistic development goals and practices. Our mission has never changed. It has been to bring connected laptops for learning to children in the poorest and most remote locations of the world. Our mission has never been to advocate the perfect learning model or pure Open Source.

I believe the best educational tool is constructionism and the best software development method is Open Source. In some cases those are best achieved like the Trojan Horse, versus direct confrontation or isolating ourselves with perfection.

Tags: | | | | |

Posted on April 23, 2008 by Edward Cherlin in People: Negroponte

olpc negroponte
What will Negroponte say now?
OK, it's semi-official. Nicholas Negroponte is thinking out loud, where we can hear him, about running only XP on the XO.
"Eventually Windows might be the sole operating system, and Sugar would be educational software running on top of it."
Notice the words "eventually" and "might". The deal is not done, or it appears even under serious discussion with Microsoft, so it isn't fully official yet. Negroponte is famous for shooting off his mouth like this. But if he means it, I'm going to start the fork of Sugar myself.
Negroponte said he was mainly concerned with putting as many laptops as possible in children's hands.
I have written about this before. Negroponte is attempting to optimize on only one variable out of the full equation, and that only in the short term. Another major variable is source code availability for student programmers. Yes for Linux and Open Source generally, no for Windows.

Then there is cost, which is necessarily higher for Windows, because it requires more hardware than Linux. Language support is possible for any community in Linux, but in Windows it depends on the good will of Microsoft, or rather the bottom line market analysis results that Microsoft works from.

Tags: | | | | | | | |

Posted on April 11, 2008 by Edward Cherlin in People: Negroponte


Walter, Nicholas, and OLPC XO
Ivan Krstić says in his blog that he quit OLPC a few weeks ago because he was no longer to work with Walter Bender, but with an unnamed manager with no technical knowledge. Also that OLPC's kernel manager is leaving.

Walter is, in his own words, "out of the loop" now. Supposedly there will be a new CEO and COO sometime.

In the meantime, Nicholas Negroponte is the only person in charge, and he has nothing to do with the people doing the work. We are not allowed to talk with him, we cannot get questions sent to him for answers, and he will not tell anybody what is going on, except to make bizarre remarks to reporters about becoming more like Microsoft.

Well, all right, I exaggerate. I have sent in one communication that I was told would be passed on to Nicholas. But I don't exaggerate by much. I haven't heard a peep in response.

Tags: | | | | | |

Posted on April 08, 2008 by Wayan Vota in People: Negroponte

Midway through a recent OLPC News Meetup, we came up with a fun idea for a new contest:
negroponte
If this seat were yours?
If I could be Nicholas Negroponte for a day... In 100 words or less, tell us what you would do with and for OLPC if you could be Nicholas Negroponte for just one day.
The rules are pretty simple:
  1. You can entry as many times as you want
  2. OLPC News Forum readers will vote on the entries
  3. The best three responses split $50 in XOexplosion gear
  4. The deadline is April 15th
The contest started March 28th, and a few people have already started dreaming about a special day at One Laptop Per Child. Here's what they do if they were in charge of our favorite education program:

Tags: | | | | | | |

Posted on March 05, 2008 by Wayan Vota in People: Negroponte

negroponte
Ready to exit
When I read Steve Hamm's Businessweek article Negroponte Seeks a Laptop CEO, I was not surprised to hear that Nicholas Negroponte has finally realized that he's not implementing the One Laptop Per Child vision effectively:
He says the organization has been operating "almost like a terrorist group, doing almost impossible things" for three years. Now, he says, it needs to be managed "more like Microsoft."

"I am not a CEO," says Negroponte. "Management, administration, and details are my weaknesses. I'm much better at the vision, big-picture side of the house."
I saw that way back in 2006, hence the reason I started OLPC News. Today that's evident in the gaping difference between his vision of millions of laptops in children's hands worldwide in 2007, and the actual reality that OLPC has sold 500,000 laptops at most, manufactured half, but only deployed around 150,000 to date.

What did surprise me is how Negroponte expects to rescue his grand dream from becoming the next Betamax - a great platform that lost out to nimbler, more responsive and collaborative competition. Nicholas Negroponte is looking for a new CEO for OLPC.

Tags: | | | | | | | |

Posted on January 16, 2008 by Guest Writer in People: Negroponte, Prototypes: XO


Nicholas Negroponte of OLPC
Nick, you may have the impression that some people are opposed to One Laptop Per Child because they speak of OLPC's latest activities in less than glowing terms. The criticisms can seem harsh but that is because they see matters that need to be corrected for the good of the program.

They, we, me, really believe that OLPC is a fantastic, exciting, and groundbreaking endeavor. That's why so many of us spend so much time thinking, talking, and writing about One Laptop Per Child.

I am writing to you because many great things have happened regarding OLPC, some sooner than I expected, and I believe these events require OLPC to change its strategy. The Age of Low-Cost Computing has arrived in large part do to your efforts. Job well-done. The Asus eee, Everex GPC, Intel Classmate (the horror!), KPC, and others flocked to a market that you created.

The entry en masse of commercial companies also complicates OLPC's status as a non-profit organization that produces a good in direct competition with private companies. Non-profits are meant to address public goods not met by the private market. Soon this will no longer be the case.

Tags: | | | | | | | |

Posted on January 09, 2008 by Wayan Vota in Sales Talk: Intel, People: Negroponte


Paul Otellini + Classmate PC
Oh the Intel + OLPC drama gets better by the day! Yesterday we learned from Darren Waters that Paul Otellini felt that Nicholas Negroponte's accusations that Intel failed to live up to its agreement with OLPC were "hogwash".

When Nicholas Negroponte heard this, he posed a very valid question to why he was badmouthing Intel all over the Internets:
"Why would I throw away the six million dollars they were supposed to give us yesterday? Why would I do all of these things unless I was stark raving mad?"
Today I wonder if he is. Why? Because look what he told Dan Nystedt of IDG News Service
"It was very unfortunate what happened with Intel, and I hope there's a way of rebuilding it in the future because there's no interest in OLPC pushing Intel out. It just is not in our interest. Our goal is to get this to as many children as possible," said Nicholas Negroponte, chairman of OLPC, in an interview.

He called it unfortunate that Intel made statements that OLPC asked the chipmaker to stop working on the Classmate PC. "The picture that painted was one of OLPC being anti-competition, which is ridiculous. We'd like to see as many laptops out there as possible and kids have the widest choice possible," he said.
He also said something similar to Reena Jana of BusinessWeek yesterday. But that's not what Negroponte told David Kirkpatrick early this week. Then he was very clear on OLPC's grievances:

Tags: | | | | | | | | | |

Posted on January 08, 2008 by Wayan Vota in People: Negroponte

olpc negroponte
What will Negroponte say now?
Now that an Intel XO-2 is out, what do you think will be Nicholas Negroponte's Industry Insider address at International CES?

I think his speech on the role of technology in economic development will still be shocking - he should announce that OLPC has achieved the mythical "$100 laptop" price point.

How? First, OLPC just announced that G1G1 raised $35 million dollars with the sale of 165,000 X0 laptops - half (82,500) destined for Haiti, Rwanda, Cambodia, Mongolia, Afghanistan.

Tags: | | | | | | |

Posted on November 30, 2007 by Wayan Vota in People: Leadership, People: Negroponte, Commentary: Press

Wow! OLPC Foundation now has its own YouTube channel and Nicholas Negroponte has just gone off the deep end of hubris. In his flagship video on why governments should spend millions on the XO laptop when their population may be poor, starving, or even lack clean water, Negroponte has announced that:
[The XO laptop] is probably the only hope. I don’t want to place too much on OLPC, but if I really had to look at how to eliminate poverty, create peace, and work on the environment, I can't think of a better way to do it.

I love me some clock stopping hot XO technology, but an instant middle class? World peace? An end to global warming? Might that be a bit of a stretch for a little green computer? And a slight egotistical leap for a MIT professor? I say we take this conversation to the comments section, where we can make OLPC News in the mold of Walter Bender's XO-enabled classroom:
We're giving them this environment where they can be expressive, they can be critics, they can engage in discourse and dialogue, and beat up on ideas, and that is where learning happens.
Especially since OLPC has turned off comments on the videos themselves - stifling the very debate they promote.

Tags: | | | | | | |

Posted on November 24, 2007 by Wayan Vota in Sales Talk: Competition, Sales Talk: Countries, Sales Talk: Intel, People: Negroponte, Countries: Nigeria, Commentary: Press, Software: Windows

Today's Wall Street Journal front page has long article on One Laptop Per Child: A Little Laptop With Big Ambitions. In it, Steve Stecklow takes the position that a computer for the poor was stomped by tech giants:
I'd like to take the position that if OLPC is getting stomped (and I don't think its being "stomped" at all), its due to its own foolishness and arrogance, as much or more than any underhanded competition from Intel or Microsoft.

Tags: | | | | | | | | |

Posted on October 25, 2007 by Wayan Vota in Sales Talk: Countries, Sales Talk: Donors, Countries: Mongolia, People: Negroponte

In the midst of Give Many participant, and he's a character.

OLPC donor John L. Thornton
John L. Thornton, Professor and Director of Global Leadership at Tsinghua University in Beijing and former President and former Co-COO of Goldman Sachs, so he's not only able to donate XO's, he also knows how to execute a successful implementation. And he is also an Intel director and Chairman of the Finance Committee of the Board, which makes his One Laptop Per Child connection all that more interesting:
President Nambaryn Enkhbayar of Mongolia announced today his commitment to provide every child in his nation with a connected laptop by the end of 2010.

As a first step toward making this a reality Professor Nicholas Negroponte, and Mr. Nyamaa Enkhbold, Minister for Foreign Affairs of Mongolia, agreed to launch the OLPC initiative in Mongolia as early as January 2008 and signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) thereof in the presence of President Enkhbayar.
.

Tags: | | | | | |

Posted on October 02, 2007 by Wayan Vota in Commentary: Academia, People: Negroponte, Commentary: OLPC News, Commentary: Press

Recently, Fake Steve Jobs had a blistering commentary on One laptop Per Child. He encapsulated the reality of an entire year's worth of OLPC fantasy in 675 concise words of biting satire. Starting with over-the-top sarcasm, he pointed out the major flaws of the OLPC leadership in developing the XO-1 laptop:
Frankly I'm shocked to see these guys having problems. I mean, a brand new hardware design, a new screen technology, a customized Linux operating system, a one-off user interface, and the customers are the poorest nations in the world, …and the whole project will be run by woolly academics who have never even worked in a real company let alone run one. What could possibly go wrong?
But FSJ saved his most stinging critique for the press corps that fawned all over Nicholas Negroponte and his band of merry men. The very people the public trusts to do the due diligence on new ideas and new initiatives.

Tags: | | | | | |

Posted on September 25, 2007 by Wayan Vota in People: Negroponte, Commentary: Press, Content: Reference


Negroponte scared of child bloggers?!
Did you read about One Laptop Per Child's Give 1 Get 1 (G1G1) program to sell XO-1 laptops to North Americans in the New York Times? If so, did you catch this insightful paragraph:
"Staff members of the laptop project were concerned that American children might try the pared-down machines and find them lacking compared to their Apple, Hewlett-Packard or Dell laptops.

Then, in this era of immediate global communications, they might post their criticisms on Web sites and blogs read around the world, damaging the reputation of the XO Laptop, the project staff worried."
Now let's think about that a minute. Do you mean to tell me that OLPC was afraid of initial childrens' reviews of XO technology?

That their award-winning design, which Nicholas Negroponte believes would create an implementation miracle, might be panned by children bloggers?